Comparing the 1974 film and baz luhrmanns adaptation. I think that many people misinterpreted the directors goal here. The screenplay for this adaptation was written by australian screenwriters craig pearce. The first big adaptation of the great gatsby came in 1949, just as the book was becoming. It was lonely for a day or so until one morning some man. In the beginning of the movie, nick is sailing a boat and then meets tom at the dock, while tom was just. The movie added the therapist, an interesting touch.
There was a lot of thins borrowed from the book, but there was a lot changed as well. The great gatsby 1974 the 1974 version of the great gatsby sometimes referred to as the robert redford great gatsby was hollywoods second attempt at adapting the novel, and by all accounts everyone involved was working a lot harder to do the book justice. The cover of the great gatsby and a poster for the film. The story primarily concerns the young and mysterious millionaire jay gatsby and his quixotic passion and obsession with the beautiful former debutante daisy buchanan. Book vs film adapting a book like the great gatsby into a film is both an incredibly difficult challenge and ridiculously easy. I know she comments on toms infidelity in the book. For example, the details from gatsby in the book always throwing lavished parties that the neighborhood attended. The other oneroom scene in the book, when daisy, gatsby and tom have it out in a stifling suite in the plaza hotel, is similarly full of anger, violence.
Comparing the movie the great gatsby and the book cram. The great gatsby has been on my to read list of classic literature for a long time. The greater great gatsby the book the great gatsby has been depicted by lots of films, but the two that stand out the most are the 1974 and the 20 versions. In both the movie and the novel, gatsby s funeral turns out disappointing. Differences between movie and book free essay example. When tom gets a call at home, daisy knows it is his mistress. Nick carraway characters tom buchanan leonardo dicaprio as jay gatsby carey mulligan as daisy buchanan tobey maguire as nick carraway joel egerton as tom buchanan elizabeth debicki as jordan baker isla fisher as myrtle wilson similarities he is meek, awkward background character. Gatsby obsessive jon reiner analyzes the liberties that baz luhrmann takes. Mia ferrow she portrayed daisy as a lot more sympathetic and nicer 20.
Fitzgerald named nick carraway, because he gets carried away into the story. In the movie, nobody shows up at all, which adds to the. It has about five direct changes from the book that i can think of off the top of my head, and only one of them is important. What are the differences between movie and book the great. Carey mulligan she potrayed her character in a tone that makes her feel more cruel and detached. The movie followed the plot of book very closely and portrayed the setting of the book very well. It had a really large budget, brought in francis ford coppola to adapt the. However, in the novel, two people show up to gatsby s funeral. Essay for the great gatsby the plot and the setting of book and movie are very similar. First of all, almost all the chararters names play an important role. All throughout grade school and even high school, my teachers, parents, and even friends told me not to take the easy way out when it comes to books. Okay, this will be my last question relating to the great gatsby, i promise. Today ill be looking at the 1925 novel the great gatsby by f. The movie, the great gatsby, was created in 20, and based on the book of the same name by f.
Gatsby loomed so large in the original story that its not hard to forget all about nick. The great gatsby similarities to the movie showing 2. Differences between the great gatsby book and movie book. Fitgeralds story, told from nicks firstperson point of view, was only as good as nicks narration. The1974 movie has strengths and weaknesses when comparing it to the book as does the 20 version. It would be fun not to know that baz luhrmanns new movie is an adaptation, not to have read the book that its an adaptation of, not to bother.
Spoilers of both the novel and the movie are included in this post, and this is a longer post than i normally blog, but considering the buzz around this movie, i thought it was warranted. The great gatsby movie vs book by jennyfer elizarraraz on prezi next. There are many spoilers in the great gatsby book to movie comparison. The great gatsby book while the movie did remain loyal to the book at big times, it did skimp out on some other juicy details. I had a dog, at least i had him for a few days until he ran away, and an old dodge and a finnish woman who made my bed and cooked breakfast and muttered finnish wisdom to herself over the electric stove. Anyone feel like throwing a gatsbyesque party and inviting me. Comparison of both the 20 and 1974 film adaptions of f. The great gatsby 20 frequently asked questions imdb. Actually, this is true of both the book and the film, but you cant exactly have nick unknowingly interacting with gatsby when hes played by leonardo dicaprio. Baz luhrmanns the great gatsby was never going to be perfect. Especially compared to the more raucous 20 version, this is.
There was no picture of him with his class in the book. The great gatsby by f scott fitzgerald 5 book vs movie. Actually, this is true of both the book and the film, but you cant exactly have nick unknowingly interacting with gatsby. In the book, fitzgerald makes it so that it is clear to the reader that daisy purposly ran her, over, that daisy noticed her but kept going because she knew of the affair, but in the movie, when the gatsby is telling nick carraway about what happened he emphasizes multiple time how it was an accident and daisy was stressed. Daisy does not show to the funeral in both the movie and the book. Baz luhrmans the great gatsby presented a whole different kind of experience for me. Over the past two weeks, i finally read through gatsby and watched both the 20 film adaptation and the. The great gatsby book and movie comparison by emilee may. The great gatsby 20 film study guide contains a biography of director baz luhrmann, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. Scott fitzgeralds the great gatsby is widely considered to be one of the greatest pieces of american literature. The great gatsby is a book known by millions of people in the world.
Scott fitzgeralds novel, the great gatsby, and baz. But, i must know, which version of the great gatsby is better. Gatsby is as dangerous as a gat slang for gun daisy faye was given her name because she looks be. But it can be argued, and often is, that it was nick and not gatsby who was the protagonist of the novel. Ok, then, lets compare the characters in the two great gatsby movies, head to head jay gatsby. If you dont remember, it was on my summer box office mustsees list, and we saw it as soon as it came out. Fitzgeralds nick does refer to gatsby as the man who gives his name to this book emphasis mine, so the idea that the great gatsby is a text written by nick is not entirely original with luhrmannthough the filmmaker takes this much further than fitzgerald, showing nick writing by hand, then typing. It is the fifth time fitzgeralds novel has been brought to the screen, preceded by the great gatsby 1926 1926, the great gatsby 1949 1949, the great gatsby 1974 1974, and the great gatsby 2000 2000. Critics and audiences generally complained about a lack of accuracy to the book and overall entertainment level, though the 1974 adaption is generally considered a good historical costume movie. Included here is a straightforward and specific twopage worksheet for students to evaluate how 20 the great gatsby movie differs from the novella, which can be easily adapted to any of the movie versions of the book. I havent yet been able to see the 1974 version, yet, but i want to know what people think of it.
What are some differences between the book great gatsby. I usually took the easy way out, watched the movie, and then skim the book. The film was cowritten and directed by baz luhrmann and stars leonardo dicaprio as the eponymous jay gatsby, with tobey maguire, carey mulligan, joel edgerton, isla fisher and elizabeth debicki. Scott fitzgeralds seminal book, it is almost impossible to have this discussion without addressing the other. The differences in fitzgerald 1925 novel and baz luhrmann 20 film are easily spotted due to the different timelines. As portrayed in the book, he was a sturdy strawhaired man, with a rather hard mouth whose arrogant eyes had established dominance over his face and not even his clothes could hide the enormous power of his body. Scott fitzgerald that follows a cast of characters living in the fictional towns of west egg and east egg on prosperous long island in the summer of 1922. Great gatsby movie vs book by jillian tereshka on prezi. How is daisy portrayed in the film and novel the great gatsby.
In the book, gatsby went to oggsford if you say it out loud it sounds like oxford which he intentionally wanted to make it sound like. What are the differences between movie and book the great gatsby. Usually, we all know that the book is better than the movie. Hey everyone, so, have you seen the great gatsby yet. Student writing is emphasized, with a specific prompt for students to include a term of contrast in their analysis. Each film had very similar characteristics, but i believe that that is only because they are both based off the same book. For an actor, the chief obstacle against making gatsby great on film is gatsby himself. The great gatsby is also a 1925 novel by american author f. Fitzgeralds nick does refer to gatsby as the man who gives his name to this book emphasis mine, so the idea that the great gatsby is a text written by nick is not entirely original with. As in the book, jay gatsby is a twodimensional self creation that luhrmann instead shows us in 3d to no.
Books give you creative license to cast whomever you want, have. Was born poor but then became rich and successful self educated and. Unfortunately, the same triumph isnt achieved in the principal characters. On the one hand, the novel, written by f scott fitzgerald and published in 1925, is one of the most beloved and wellknown novels of the 20th century. Curious about the different film adaptations of the great gatsby. The great gatsby by f scott fitzgerald 5 book vs movie changes explained duration. The great gatsby is a 20 romantic drama film based on f. The great gatsby meets baz luhrmann books the guardian.
The list is quite long, and i add books onto it much more often than i cross them off. The great gatsby is a 1925 novel written by american author f. As for the 20 gatsby, id forgotten that luhrmanns films always overwhelm me when i first see them. As in the book, jay gatsby is a twodimensional self creation that luhrmann instead shows us in 3d to no substantial storytelling benefit.
1408 1365 177 249 62 66 705 386 160 1008 579 949 635 706 1222 1233 728 376 629 771 1048 781 446 1176 373 364 66 1277 719 1006 49 250